Aug 07, 2008 - 04:30 AM
By Dirk van der Werf
There was a heading in one of our local newspapers the other day which struck me. We've all heard the line before. "Rich Get Richer."
"And the poor get poorer," we all respond, in unison. It's not all that odd. Isn't it always the case? But it does make one stop and think. As always, I look for solutions to this alleged problem. This may be because I am a former math teacher! I am constantly looking for ways to improve the lot of mankind.
There are two variables at play here. The first is the question, "Why is this happening? Is it even a bad thing?" And secondly we must ask ourselves, "What are the ramifications of policies which lead to this gradual widening of the gap between rich and poor?"
In answer to the first question, when our economy is doing sufficiently well, it allows those who have the wherewithal to invest to reap ever greater profits. Not a bad idea, as long as there is some sharing going on.
So how do you suppose we can stem the widening gap? How can we hold the uber-rich non-elected leaders of our societies more accountable? An interesting example of un-solicited leadership in this regard is Warren Buffet. He is, undoubtedly, one of the richest people on Earth, and one of its greatest philanthropists, via his Buffet Foundation. And he intends to give more than 80 per cent of his net worth to the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation upon his death.
But not all the super-wealthy of the world are so generous. Many of them are, in fact, rather stingy. Should they be held accountable? Should they be forced to share?
One sure way of doing this, of course, is by taxing them. We of the middle class shudder when we hear the word "taxes" because reducing our net income from a comfortable $35,000 to a not-so-comfortable $29,000 has a visceral effect on our ability to deal with life. Not so the reduction of someone's net from $35 million to $29 million.
But if you changed the regime of taxation to one where anyone who earns less than around $40,000 doesn't pay any taxes, while the very wealthy may pay up to 80 per cent... I can hear a sigh! Wouldn't it be nice?
In Europe, the rich pay a much higher rate of taxes than those less fortunate. And they pride themselves in doing so! No flat tax there. Whereas in America -- where we, unfortunately, get a lot of our directives -- they pride themselves on having more millionaires per capita than any other country in the world, while they have 30 million citizens who don't have health care.
The second variable in the equation is this. What are the effects of having this widening gap between the rich and the poor? Most often, not all are included in the wonderful increases in profits the rich enjoy. As a matter of fact, there are some countries -- oil-rich countries like Nigeria and the Sudan -- where the poor don't share in the wealth of their countries at all. And when there is this gap, the poor have a tendency to rise up, either in a criminal way or as a movement or revolution.
There was an interesting comment made by one of Steve Paikin's guest on "The Agenda" just recently. This fellow said that the greatest contributor to crime -- a.k.a. civil unrest -- was the size of the gap between the rich and the poor. As an example of this he pointed to the country of South Africa, where there is still a huge gap between the white farmers and the black citizens of the Townships. There the crime/murder rate is even higher than that of Texas. And conversely, countries where there is a high degree of social welfare -- without being especially hard on the capitalists -- have a much lower crime rate. I guess the taxation occurs at the individual level and not at the corporate level.
So which way do we as Canadians want to see our country going? Must we always reward the rich man or should we focus a little more on the "sharing" part? You tell me!
Durham resident Dirk van der Werf likes to mull over the state of the world. He is a frequent contributor to this space.
Recommend :
More Columns By Guest Columnist
Do a random act of kindnessWhen was the last time a stranger stopped to help you in a time of need? When was the last time you stopped to help a stranger in their time of need? Have random acts of ...
Why save Big Three's bacon?A heated debate on the rescue plan for the 'Big Three' automakers (GM, Ford and Chrysler) is raging on both sides of the border. Both governments are going through ...
Big Three only want guaranteed loans to keep operating plantsWhy is everyone calling the Big Three's request for assistance a bailout? They are asking for guaranteed loans. A bailout is what the big banks are getting to protect ...
LHINs should be first to goIt is that time once again when we in the health care industry are asked by the government to 'fall on our scalpels'. There is a vague notion that somehow trimming a ...
Bailout yes but with strings attachedThis past week our leader met with the leaders of the other major economic powers of the world to figure out exactly how best to help their own people (their taxpayers), get ...
Are we ready for sustainability?Charles Darwin's discovery of evolution is the single most important discovery for humanity in terms of educating ourselves on what it will take to sustain human life on ...
Just leave Town boundaries as they areI was somewhat dismayed as I read that Whitby Town council is planning to expand the current housing development boundary as part of the official Town plan for the next 25 ...
Everyone needs to help in crisis timesIt appears things keep getting worse for General Motors. The corporation lost $2.5 billion over the last three months, with sales down 45 per cent. There was a meeting the ...
Give the gift of loveFor almost every occasion there appears a footnote stating 'no gifts'. Each year, especially during this season, the statement becomes more and more prevalent from ...
St. John Bosco brings learning to lifeSt. John Bosco Catholic School is climbing the ladder to becoming the best school in Durham Region. It is a very friendly and welcoming environment for newcomers who visit our...