Police must stop random drug searches
May 01, 2008 - 11:07
By Josie Newman
DURHAM -- A ruling by the Supreme Court of Canada last week that police who randomly search high school lockers with sniffer dogs are breaching privacy rights has little effect here in Durham Region.
The ruling came down following the acquittal of a Sarnia high school student charged in 2002 with possession of pot for trafficking. A police and canine unit arrived unannounced at his high school and confined students to classrooms for two hours while a drug-sniffing dog led officers to a pile of students' knapsacks, where some drugs were found. Last week's ruling states police officers who use dogs to find drugs in schools or other public places must be able to justify their search based on former crimes or major drug tips.
"This has been in the legal works for quite a while so it hasn't been our practice to use police dogs for random searches for a long time," said Mark Joel, superintendent of operations and transportation at the Durham District School Board. "Many years ago, it was a practice to have them do this randomly with the schools. If it was suspected more recently that a big drug deal was going down, then we'd have private agents we'd call who use dogs."
Joe Hircock, the DDSB's Whitby schools superintendent, said the board no longer uses private agencies with sniffer dogs.
"Once the Supreme Court started their investigation in Sarnia five years ago, we stopped utilizing the service of sniffer dogs altogether," he said.
"We've never had the police come in with dogs to search," said Paul Pulla, director of education for the Durham Catholic District School Board. "We did have a private kennel who ran dogs in secondary schools who could sense explosives. They'd do demonstrations of what dogs could do to educate students about anti-drug programs. And, years ago, we had to engage a kennel to come in because we'd had a bomb threat."
"Regardless of the Supreme Court decision, kids have gotten wise. They won't put drugs in their lockers or carry them on their person," said Mr. Pulla.
"The judgment is a reasonable compromise between law-enforcement aspirations to search indiscriminately, and the right to privacy. Now they need reasonable suspicion -- not a trumped-up profile or a pretext search based on speculation," said Frank Addario, president of the Criminal Lawyer's Association.
With files from Torstar News Services
Latest News
Election called for Oct. 14Canadians will go to the polls Tuesday, Oct. 14, the day after Thanksgiving, to vote for a new federal government.
Prime
Minister Stephen Harper, who had fixed the next ...
Whitby's Abilities Centre gets $15 million from fedsWHITBY -- On the eve of a federal election call, Finance Minister Jim Flaherty is lauding a $15 million windfall announced today for his home riding of Whitby-Oshawa.The money...
Three new cars bound for Oshawa GM plant
OSHAWA -- A General Motors spokesman said today the company will be building three new cars in Oshawa, the first of which will be in production in 2010.The comments ...
General Motors, feds and Province make a deal for Oshawa
OSHAWA -- It's Christmas in September for General Motors and its Oshawa employees.An agreement reached today between GM and the federal and provincial governments means the ...
School board looks into going greenDURHAM -- The public school board is looking into what it takes to build a green school. A mild, generic investigation into the construction costs, ongoing savings, and what ...
Durham residents on board with public transitDURHAM -- As the price at the pumps soars, Durham residents are joining their fellow Canadians in migrating to public transit.Pickering resident and student Amira Rezkalla...
Hunting for flood solutionsDURHAM -- Flooded Ajax and Whitby residents had politicians on their side at a recent works committee meeting, but questions over whether they can expect relief remain. On Aug...
Dead Pickering bird ends West Nile seasonDURHAM -- A dead bird found in Pickering is the latest to test positive for West Nile virus (WNV).The crow was picked up on Sept. 2 and was the eighth bird in Durham in ...
Gas leak evacuates 10 Pickering homesPICKERING -- A gas leak on Sheppard Avenue in Pickering Thursday afternoon caused residents to evacuate their homes for more than five hours, a City official said.Everett ...
Relief for westbound commuters on Hwy. 401DURHAM REGION -- Two lanes of the westbound 401 collectors at the Don Valley Parkway have re-opened for the morning rush hour commute, however, the exit ramp to the DVP/404 on...