Uxbridge farmer said fill operation is legal
Sep 03, 2008 - 03:30 PM
By Jeff Hayward
UXBRIDGE -- The only things he's trying to hide on his Uxbridge farm, Ed Beach says, are dust and noise as trucks dump fill on the site.
Thousands of tires were dumped on his 100-acre farm between the 1950s and 1970s, to build up a ravine running through the property to control storm water erosion. He said his family has been dealing with runoff from neighbouring properties for years.
But residents' concerns have surfaced regarding possible leaching from the now-buried tires into groundwater sources.
Anne Holmes said she has been raising a red flag to local and provincial government officials about Mr. Beach's property, on Concession 2 near Wagg Road, for 15 years. "(The site) is at the headwaters of the Pefferlaw Brook," lamented Ms. Holmes.
She has also obtained a decade-old video of the site, showing countless tires dumped on the property before they were filled over. Although it is unknown exactly how many tires are buried there, the Ministry of Environment estimates as many as 70,000. But having the tires underground is a better plan than leaving them on the surface, said ministry spokeswoman Kate Jordan. "The information I have... is that there is limited leaching of any contaminants, and therefore there are no groundwater concerns related to this," she said.
Mr. Beach said he has a provincial permit to fill in the site, noting it was issued to him in the late 1990s. After sitting down with Township officials and the Ministry of Environment in 1998, it was decided it would be best to bury the tires as they were a fire hazard, said Mr. Beach.
"I'm not hiding anything, everything is legal," he said. He is also building a giant berm at the fill site that minimizes the impact of construction noise and dust on neighbours, he added. "I only allow two local (trucking) companies to bring in fill, to reduce the traffic," he said.
Mr. Beach noted the 10-year-old video of the unburied tires on the property, delivered to Ms. Holmes from an unknown source, required someone to trespass on his farm to record it. "The video is illegal," he said.
When asked how long the Township has known about the tires on the Beach farm, Debbie Leroux, Uxbridge's clerk, noted, "We know a certificate of approval was issued in 1999."
She said the Township is now looking into the matter because "we're getting complaints... we're investigating."
Ms. Leroux said the Township is determining if the fill being used falls within the guidelines of the provincial permit. "If it's outside the certificate of approval... then we'll have to decide if the (Township) bylaw applies and ensure steps to make sure (the site) complies."
She added a provincial permit would "trump" any bylaw Uxbridge passed to stop the operation if Mr. beach is operating within permit guidelines.
Meanwhile, residents such as Ms. Holmes plan to continue taking action in the matter. "How can anyone give a permit for this?" she asked. "I want these tires removed and shredded."
- with files from Torstar
Recommend :
Latest News
Man charged in attack on couple back in court Jan. 22OSHAWA -- The case of a man accused of assaulting two women outside an Oshawa elementary school is due back in court later this month. A judicial pretrial session is set Jan...
Hells Angels trial winding downOSHAWA -- Jurors are expected to begin deliberations next week in the case of two Hells Angels accused of conspiring to murder an underworld rival. The trial of Remond Akleh...
Dances to aid Ajax legion, charitiesAJAX -- Canadian troops serving overseas and the Ajax Legion will benefit from an upcoming dance. The Over 30 Dance and Social Club is hosting the event on Friday, Jan. 23...
Carjackings linked, cops sayPICKERING -- Police are exploring the possibility that two recent carjackings were carried out by the same suspects. Durham cops are seeking the public's assistance as they...
Ajax snowplow, car tangleAJAX -- There was minor damage when a car and a Town snowplow bumped against each other Wednesday morning. The incident happened at about 7 a.m. when the plow turned south...
Gun pointed at woman's head in robberyAJAX -- Two teenaged suspects are being sought by police investigating a street level robbery in Ajax in which a woman had a gun held to her head. The 26-year-old victim told...
Residents oppose north Ajax highriseAJAX -- A developer's plan for a 15-storey condominium was received with less-than open arms during an information session on Tuesday. Dunbury Developments is proposing the...
Company hired to help restore St. FrancisAJAX -- A company has been hired to do interior restoration work on the former St. Francis de Sales Church. Rutherford Contracting will be paid almost $104,000 to do the first...
More snow, freezing rain on the wayOSHAWA - Residents should keep shovels handy and snow-blowers tuned up as this latest blast of wintery weather is expected to continue throughout today into the early evening...
Woman forced into van, sexually assaultedOSHAWA -- A woman was sexually assaulted by a man who forced her into his van last Friday in Oshawa. Durham police are seeking assistance in identifying the man, who...